The short answer
Use MRS for lactobacilli, M17 for Lactococcus lactis and Streptococcus thermophilus, and MRS with added cysteine or a dedicated medium for bifidobacteria. When a sample carries a heavy background flora and you want to pick out the lactobacilli alone, use the more selective Lactobacillus Selection medium. No single medium grows all lactic acid bacteria well, so a product that contains several groups of organisms normally needs as many media, each handled separately.
The media at a glance
| Medium | Best suited to | Main carbon source | Features | Typical uses |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MRS | Lactobacilli, pediococci, Leuconostoc | Glucose | The richest in nutrients, with Tween 80 and manganese; weakly selective | Reviving strains, seed cultures, lactic acid bacteria counts |
| M17 | Lactococcus lactis, Streptococcus thermophilus | Lactose | Buffered with glycerophosphate, so the cocci keep growing after they have produced acid | Dairy starter cultures, counting the cocci in yoghurt, phage assays |
| Lactobacillus Selection | Lactobacilli | Mainly glucose | High acetate concentration and low pH; strongly suppresses other organisms | Isolating lactobacilli from faecal, oral and environmental samples |
| Elliker | Lactic streptococci and lactobacilli in dairy products | Glucose, lactose and sucrose (traditional formulation) | All three sugars, so it suits dairy cultures across the board | Routine culture and counts in dairy plants |
| Bifidobacterium Agar | Bifidobacteria | Depends on the formulation | Designed for anaerobic bifidobacteria | Culture and enumeration of bifidobacteria in probiotic products |
MRS: the first choice for lactobacilli
MRS is the most complete of these media nutritionally. It has glucose, three nitrogen sources, Tween 80 and manganese, and almost all lactobacilli, pediococci and Leuconostoc grow well on it. Its weakness is limited selectivity: yeasts and some Bacillus species grow too, and in counts this is dealt with by lowering the pH and incubating anaerobically. For composition and preparation, see What is MRS medium?
M17: the first choice for cocci
Lactococcus lactis and Streptococcus thermophilus perform inconsistently on MRS. M17 uses lactose as the carbon source, the sugar dairy starter cultures are most accustomed to. Its buffer is glycerophosphate, so when the cocci produce acid the pH does not fall straight to a level that inhibits them, and the colonies are large and distinct. M17 is also the standard medium for bacteriophage testing in dairy cultures. With some M17 base media the lactose has to be added separately; follow the product instructions. STBIO's products are M17 Agar Base and M17 Broth.
Lactobacillus Selection: samples with a heavy background flora
Media of this type are often called LBS or Rogosa media. The acetate concentration is far higher than in MRS and the pH is lower, so most organisms other than lactic acid bacteria fail to grow. The price is that some lactobacilli are inhibited as well, and counts are somewhat lower than on MRS. These media suit samples such as faeces, oral samples and silage, in which other organisms far outnumber the lactic acid bacteria. STBIO's products are Lactobacillus Selection Agar Base and Lactobacillus Selection Broth Base.
Elliker: everyday culture in the dairy plant
The traditional Elliker formulation contains glucose, lactose and sucrose together, so both the streptococci and the lactobacilli common in dairy products grow on it. It suits routine subculture of starter cultures and general counts. Its buffering is weaker than that of M17 and its growth factors are less complete than those of MRS; it is a general-purpose medium. STBIO offers a modified formulation, Modified Elliker Agar, and a broth version. The composition is as stated on the specification sheet.
Bifidobacteria: anaerobic conditions are what matter
Bifidobacteria are sensitive to oxygen, and their nutritional requirements differ from those of lactobacilli. There are two approaches:
- MRS with cysteine. Add about 0.05% L-cysteine hydrochloride to lower the redox potential and incubate under strictly anaerobic conditions. This is sufficient for reviving and growing pure cultures.
- A dedicated medium. When a product contains both lactobacilli and bifidobacteria and the bifidobacteria have to be counted on their own, use a dedicated selective medium. The international standard ISO 29981 | IDF 220 uses TOS propionate agar with mupirocin. STBIO offers Bifidobacterium Agar.
Choosing by product
Yoghurt and fermented milks. Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus on acidified MRS and Streptococcus thermophilus on M17, counted separately. This is the approach of ISO 7889 | IDF 117.
Probiotic powders and capsules. MRS for the total lactic acid bacteria count. When individual organisms are declared on the label, add a selective agent or change the medium according to the organism: MRS with antibiotics for Lactobacillus acidophilus, a dedicated medium for bifidobacteria.
Kimchi, pickled vegetables and sourdough. The flora is mainly lactobacilli, Leuconostoc and pediococci; use MRS at 30 °C. Where the sample carries many yeasts, incubate anaerobically and run confirmation tests.
Cheese and dairy starter cultures. Lactococcus lactis on M17 at 30 °C; thermophilic starters on M17 at a higher temperature.
Production fermentation. MRS is a formulation for the laboratory and the seed stage, and its cost makes it unsuitable for scaling up directly to the fermenter. Production normally moves to an in-house formulation of peptone, yeast extract and sugar. For how to pick the nitrogen source, see How do I choose a nitrogen source for fermentation?
FAQ
I only have MRS. Can I grow Streptococcus thermophilus on it? It will grow, but not well: the colonies are small and the counts are low. For counts or long-term subculture, use M17.
Are MRS and Rogosa medium the same thing? No. Rogosa was one of the authors of MRS, which is why the two are easily confused. "Rogosa medium" normally refers to an earlier and more selective formulation, the Lactobacillus Selection type described above.
How many media does one sample need? It depends on how many groups of organisms the product contains and how finely the label separates them. For a total count, MRS alone is enough. To separate rods from cocci you need at least two media, and with bifidobacteria as well, three.
Are Halal versions of these media available? MRS is available in food-grade Halal versions as both broth and agar; see the MRS media range. For the certification status of the other media, see the individual product pages.
For the conditions each test method specifies, see How to count lactic acid bacteria.
