STBIO MEDIAST BIO, INC.STBIO MEDIA, INC.

Poor Growth on MRS Agar: Small Colonies, Low Counts or Unwanted Organisms, Checked One by One

Written and reviewed by the STBIO technical teamPublished

The short answer

When lactic acid bacteria grow poorly on MRS, the cause is usually the conditions and not a faulty medium. The three most common causes are incubating in an ordinary incubator with no anaerobic atmosphere, over-sterilising the medium, and plating cells that have not yet recovered from freezing or freeze-drying. Rule these three out first, and then look at pH, plate drying and the special requirements of the species. Other organisms growing on the plates is a separate problem, because MRS was never a strictly selective medium.

Slow growth and very small colonies

1. No anaerobic incubation

Most lactic acid bacteria will grow in air, but the colonies are much smaller and with some strains are barely visible. Move the plates to an anaerobic jar, or use an incubator with about 5% CO₂. The gas-generating sachet must be within its expiry date and the indicator must have changed colour; a leaking jar gasket is a common weak point. Adding an agar overlay to pour plates also reduces contact with oxygen.

2. Temperature and time

Optimum temperatures differ widely among lactic acid bacteria: about 30 °C for the mesophilic lactic acid bacteria in foods, 35 to 37 °C for most lactobacilli, and around 42 °C for thermophilic strains. At the wrong temperature there may be nothing to see after 48 hours. Lactic acid bacteria also grow more slowly than E. coli, so incubate for at least the full 48 to 72 hours before judging.

3. Over-sterilisation

MRS contains 2% glucose. The longer it is heated, the further the sugar reacts with amino acids: nutrients are lost and compounds that inhibit growth are formed. Cells usually grow poorly in MRS that has come out dark brown. Autoclave at 121 °C for 15 minutes, remove the medium as soon as the cycle ends, do not sterilise it twice, and do not hold it for long periods in a water bath. For the reasons, see Is it normal for a medium to darken or turn cloudy after autoclaving?

4. Wrong pH

The pH of MRS after autoclaving is generally 6.2 to 6.5. When the pH is lowered to between 5.4 and 5.7 to raise selectivity, some strains grow more slowly or not at all; that is a trade-off built into the method. If the pH is low and you have not acidified the medium on purpose, check the sterilisation conditions first: see Medium pH drops after autoclaving.

5. Plates too dry or too wet

Poured plates that have been kept too long dry out at the surface, and the colonies are smaller still. Conversely, if the surface is still wet when the plate is spread, the colonies run together. Keep plates bagged and refrigerated, use them within their shelf life, and let surface moisture evaporate before use.

6. The cells have not recovered

Cells recovered from a frozen vial, a freeze-dried powder or a finished product are injured. Plated directly, a proportion of them will not grow. Revive the strain through one or two transfers in MRS broth before further work. For a count, where enrichment beforehand is not permitted, allow enough rehydration time in the diluent, and do not use cold diluent.

7. The species has extra requirements

  • Bifidobacteria: strictly anaerobic. Add about 0.05% L-cysteine hydrochloride to MRS, or go straight to Bifidobacterium Agar.
  • Streptococcus thermophilus and Lactococcus lactis: growth on MRS is less than ideal. Use M17 instead.
  • Some fastidious lactobacilli: need a lower oxygen level or a particular sugar. Compare different media side by side.

For the media that suit each group of lactic acid bacteria, see MRS vs M17 and other media for lactic acid bacteria.

Other organisms growing on the plates

MRS relies on sodium acetate and ammonium citrate to hold back some competing organisms, but they do not stop everything. The usual intruders and what to do about them:

What grows How to recognise it What to do
Yeasts Larger, raised, cream and opaque colonies; large oval cells under the microscope Incubate anaerobically; add an antifungal agent where the method allows it
Bacillus Large, flat colonies with irregular edges; catalase-positive Lower the pH to between 5.4 and 5.7; incubate anaerobically
Enterococci, staphylococci Colonies look similar to lactic acid bacteria; cocci; staphylococci are catalase-positive Confirm by Gram stain and catalase test and exclude from the count

The basic criteria for confirming lactic acid bacteria are Gram-positive and catalase-negative. For samples with a heavy background flora, consider the more selective Lactobacillus Selection Agar Base. For the general reasons why selective media fail, see When a selective medium lets the wrong organisms grow.

MRS broth that does not turn turbid

If MRS broth is still clear a day or two after inoculation, check in this order:

  1. Whether the inoculum was large enough. The first transfer of a freeze-dried culture usually takes longer.
  2. Whether the temperature suits the strain.
  3. Whether the broth is too dark, in other words over-sterilised.
  4. Whether the tubes are filled too shallow or shaken too much, exposing the cells to too much oxygen. Static incubation in well-filled tubes works better.

For general troubleshooting of a long lag phase, see A long lag phase after inoculation.

When to suspect the medium

Once everything above has been ruled out, run one check with a reference strain: inoculate the same strain onto the old and the new batch of MRS at the same time and compare colony size and recovery. Only a clear difference points to the medium. STBIO ships a COA with every batch, and the specification sheets for the food-grade MRS products list the reference strains used for the growth performance test, which you can use for comparison.

FAQ

The colonies of the same strain became smaller after we changed MRS brand. Why? The peptone and meat extract in MRS come from different sources from one manufacturer to another, and the pH after autoclaving also differs slightly. Fastidious strains show this in the size of their colonies. Compare side by side before changing brand, and adjust the incubation time if necessary.

There is a little sediment at the bottom of the MRS broth. Can it be used? A small amount of fine sediment or a slight opalescence does not normally affect growth. A heavy white precipitate means the pH is too high or there is a problem with the water; prepare a fresh batch, and see White precipitate after autoclaving.

The culture grows, but the pH falls quickly and the cell count stops rising. Why? This is normal for lactic acid bacteria: they inhibit themselves with the acid they produce. Production fermentations deal with it by controlling the pH. The buffer in MRS broth is sufficient only for seed cultures.

For the specifications of the five MRS products and which to choose, see the MRS media range.

Written and reviewed by the STBIO technical teamSTBIO MEDIA has produced peptones and microbial culture media since 2002, with ISO 22000 and Halal certification and an in-house QC laboratory.

Further reading